By failing to stop the use of the designation ‘Feta’ for cheese intended for export to third countries, Denmark has failed to fulfil its obligations under EU law
However, Denmark has not infringed the obligation of sincere cooperation
Bild von PDPhotos auf Pixabay
In the present infringement proceedings, the Commission, supported by Greece and Cyprus, claims that Denmark has breached its obligations under Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 2 by failing to prevent or stop the use of the designation ‘Feta’ on cheese produced in Denmark and intended for export to third countries.
However, Denmark maintains that Regulation No 1151/2012 applies only to products sold in the European Union
and does not cover exports to third countries. It therefore does not deny that it has neither prevented nor stopped
producers in its territory from using the name ‘Feta’ if their products are intended for export to third countries.
In its judgment delivered today, the Court of Justice notes in the first place that, according to the wording of
Regulation No 1151/2012, the use of a registered name to designate products not covered by the registration which are produced in the European Union and intended for export to third countries is not excluded from the prohibition laid down in that regulation.
As regards, in the second place, the context of Regulation No 1151/2012, the Court points out that PDOs and
protected geographical indications (PGIs) are protected as an intellectual property right by Regulation
No 1151/2012. The scheme for PDOs and PGIs has been established in order to help producers of products linked to a geographical area by ensuring uniform protection of the names as an intellectual property right in the territory of the European Union. The use of a PDO or PGI to designate a product produced in the territory of the European Union which does not comply with the applicable product specification impairs, within the European Union, the intellectual property right constituted by that PDO or PGI, even if that product is intended for export to third countries.
In the third place, regarding the objectives pursued by Regulation No 1151/2012, the Court states that the objective of PDOs and PGIs is to help producers of products linked to a geographical area by securing fair returns for the qualities of their products, by ensuring uniform protection of the names as an intellectual property right in the territory of the European Union, and by providing clear information on the value-adding attributes of the product to consumers. The use of the PDO ‘Feta’ to designate products produced in the territory of the European Union which do not comply with the product specification for that PDO undermines those objectives, even if those products are intended for export to third countries.
It therefore follows from the wording of Regulation No 1151/2012, as well as from its context and the objectives pursued by it, that such use constitutes conduct prohibited by that regulation. The Court concludes that, by failing to prevent or stop such use in its territory, Denmark has failed to fulfil its obligations under Regulation No 1151/2012.
In response to the second complaint raised by the Commission, the Court considers that Denmark has not
infringed its obligation under the principle of sincere cooperation referred to in Article 4(3) TEU. That complaint
refers to the same conduct as that which forms the subject matter of the first complaint, namely the failure to
prevent or stop Danish producers from using the PDO ‘Feta’ to designate cheese which does not comply with the applicable product specification. Although it is true that the export to third countries by EU producers of products unlawfully using a PDO is likely to weaken the European Union’s position in international negotiations aimed at ensuring the protection of EU quality schemes, it has not been established that Denmark has taken any action or made any statements potentially having that effect, which would constitute conduct distinct from that which forms the subject matter of the first complaint.
Other news from the department politics & laws
The Vegan Society celebrates 30 years of legal recognition for veganism
2023 marks 30 years since veganism was first recognised in law
Formula milk trials are not reliable, warn experts
Recent trials lack scientific rigour; substantial change needed to protect participants from harm and protect consumers from misleading information
Most read news
Extracting the best flavor from coffee
Understanding the origin of uneven extraction in brewing espresso can improve the beverage and enable substantial financial savings by using coffee more efficiently and sustainably
What makes “junk food” junk?
Study examines how three decades of U.S. policies define junk food for taxation and other regulations
Paper-based packaging has a good eco-image
Study by the University of Bonn examines how the type of packaging influences purchase intention
More news from our other portals
Newly developed hydrogel nanocomposite for the mass production of hydrogen
“This study makes great progress in the field of photocatalysis and showcases the potential of green hydrogen production at sea with world-class performance"
Microbe of the Year 2023: Bacillus subtilis – for health and technology
Already, Bacillus subtilis is indispensable in many industries, and many more innovations are expected
Electronic noses sniff out volatile organic compounds
Improving the fluid flow inside noselike chambers can enhance detection of harmful chemicals
Artificial photosynthesis for environmentally friendly food production
Researchers produce important amino acid from greenhouse gas CO₂
Artificial intelligence identifies anti-aging drug candidates targeting ‘zombie’ cells
New platform has potential to fuel advances in senolytic anti-aging compounds and longevity research
New concept for lithium-air batteries
Research project in Germany aims to improve the stability of this novel battery type
Researchers develop new method to synthesise cannabis plant compound
cis-tetrahydrocannabinoids can now be produced synthetically, enabling pharmaceutical applications
X-ray imaging captures fleeting defects in sodium-ion batteries
A Cornell-led collaboration succeeded in identifying an elusive mechanism that can trigger degradation in sodium-ion batteries
Launching Revvity: A Scientific Solutions Company Powering Innovation from Discovery to Cure
The Company was previously affiliated with PerkinElmer, Inc.
New catalyst transforms carbon dioxide into sustainable byproduct
Researchers create acetic acid out of carbon monoxide derived from captured carbon
Verder Group acquires ERWEKA
With this acquisition, Verder Scientific expands its portfolio to include dissolution and tablet testing equipment for the pharmaceutical and life science sectors
New theory explains superconductivity in spun graphene trilayers
The study, carried out by CSIC scientists, lays the foundations for understanding the mechanisms of certain unconventional superconducting materials
Pall and Cytiva join forces
Cytiva and Pall Life Sciences complete integration to create a global innovation and solutions leader in biotechnology
The World’s Smallest Impedance Spectroscopy System in the Form of a Pill Finds Weak Spots in Machines and People
Small as a candy: Waterproof IoT sensor reliably measures the properties of liquids even in hard-to-reach places
Researchers harvest abundant clean energy from thin air, 24/7
“The air contains an enormous amount of electricity”
Insilico Medicine-led study combines quantum computing and generative AI for drug discovery
“Quantum computing is recognized as the next technology breakthrough which will make a great impact, and the pharmaceutical industry is believed to be among the first wave of industries benefiting from the advancement”
New Start-up develops aquafarms for macroalgae
AWI and Carbonwave spin-off: Large algae simultaneously bind CO₂ and create raw materials for the chemical industry
3D-printed pills with desired drug release – a step upwards in medication
Funny looking pills are not a design gimmick, they can release medication in a desired time regime!
Ultra-long protein fibrils give clues on dementia risk
"AFM technology has the potential to complement conventional biomarker tests and improve the early detection of Alzheimer's"
An electric vehicle battery for all seasons
New electrolyte for lithium-ion batteries performs well in frigid regions and seasons
How to repel mosquitoes with the right soap scent
Virginia Tech researchers conduct proof-of-concept study on mosquito’s scent preferences
Bioindicator for the occurrence of PFAS
The liver of wild boar indicates the level of PFAS contamination
Ammonia: efficient hydrogen carrier and green steel enabler
Max Planck materials scientists use ammonia for sustainable iron- and steelmaking