Is that glass bottle of OJ better for the planet than a plastic container?
Which packaging type for a 12-ounce, single-serve container of orange juice would you choose as the most sustainable option:
- Aluminum/canned, made with recycled material;
- Carton, described as biodegradable/compostable;
- Glass, 100% recyclable; or
- Plastic, described as biodegradable/compostable?
If you were like the U.S. consumers surveyed by food scientists in a University of Massachusetts Amherst study, you’d prefer glass and believe it was the most sustainable choice. And you all would be mistaken.
“Glass was the most sought-after and most highly esteemed packaging type,” says Nomzamo Dlamini, lead author of the paper recently published in the journal Sustainability. Dlamini, a food science Ph.D. candidate, was a recent visiting Fulbright scholar from the University of Pretoria in South Africa studying in the UMass Amherst lab of senior author Alissa Nolden, assistant professor of food science. “But it turns out, glass is actually among the least sustainable if you look at the whole packaging lifecycle,” Dlamini added.
When asked to rank the packaging choices from their perception of the most to least sustainable, overall the consumers responded: glass, carton, aluminum and plastic.
Though food packaging sustainability varies depending on the type of product and packaging, the size and weight of the container and other variables, in the case of the single-serve orange juice, a carton would be the most sustainable, followed by plastic, then canned and, finally, glass.
This came as a surprise even to Dlamini. “I was shocked to read the lifecycle assessment from the experts that it takes so much energy to produce glass and recycle it – much more than what it takes to make or recycle plastic,” she says.
The study states, “The production and end-of-life impacts of plastic are less than that of glass, plastic is lighter and thus requires less energy to transport, furthermore, the aseptic sealing process of plastic containers using steam is less energy demanding than the retort system used for glass.”
The study aimed to understand the motivation behind consumers’ packaging choices, while also weighing price, lifestyle and other attitudes. In turn, the data can help industry experts understand what consumers think, believe and prefer, and educate them on how to make more sustainable choices.
“We designed a questionnaire using a method called conjoint analysis, which mimics a real-life situation where you’re presented with various options and you have to make a trade-off,” Dlamini says. “And we try to understand at the end of the day, what matters to people. The whole idea behind the study was to get an understanding of what people think and what drives their choices.”
Nolden points out that while many consumers expressed an intention to purchase sustainable packaging, in the end the top motivating factor was price – particularly the lowest price – followed by packaging type, product claim and packaging claim.
So, the ideal orange juice option – culled from the 847 adult consumers who answered the online survey – was priced at $1.10 per 12 fluid ounces, packaged in glass, locally produced and labelled as 100% recyclable.
The message to the food industry is that consumers are motivated to choose sustainable packaging, as long as the price is right. “These sustainable packaging options should be clearly labelled as such, effective (e.g. not defective or just as durable as conventional packaging), and affordable to increase consumers’ motivation and adoption of sustainable packaging for food and beverages,” the paper states.
Ultimately, there is something even more important than choosing the best packaging when it comes to consuming food with a focus on sustainability.
“Overall, while packaging choices contribute to environmental outcomes, the most impactful and practical way consumers can contribute to sustainability efforts is to reduce or avoid food waste,” the paper concludes.
Original publication
Other news from the department science
Most read news
More news from our other portals
Last viewed contents
Back on the menu - After steep declines, US foodservice industry set to rebound to pre-pandemic levels by 2023
BENEO invests in pulse-processing plant - €50 million investment enables BENEO to extend its footprint into the fast-growing market for sustainably produced plant-based protein ingredients
Carlsberg Group completes acquisition of Britvic plc - "The Britvic acquisition is a pivotal milestone in the history of Carlsberg"
Arla creates a global organisation fit for the future
From the packet into your food: what harmful substances are in food packaging? - Database of previously undocumented chemicals
BENEO Acquires Meatless B.V. to Expand its Portfolio of Plant-based Solutions
Just as Gouda: Improving the quality of cheese alternatives - Studying how plant-based proteins interact with fat matrices can lead to better texture and nutrition for vegan cheese
How The Coca-Cola Company is Responding to the Coronavirus Outbreak
RAPS impressed at the VIP Days 2025 during IFFA above the rooftops of Frankfurt - Spice and ingredient expert RAPS presented its latest product and technology solutions to an exclusive specialist audience.
Those who are flexitarian are happier! - Representative survey by Burger King® on Eat Flexitarian Day provides surprising insights
The world's first returnable bottles made of thermally tempered lightweight glass - Echovai by Vetropack
